This week’s announcement by HP that it will take a nearly nine billion dollar write down on the $10 billion investment it made in British business intelligence software business Autonomy shows how a once proud company can be laid low by a managerial culture.
HP’s purchase of Autonomy was a classic example of the Silicon Valley greater fool exit where the founders and investors of a business find a foolish buyer – in this case HP – to overpay for the operation.
In HP’s case it appears they overpaid by $8.8 billion dollars, this follows a $8 billion dollar write down earlier this year on the 2008 acquisition of Electronic Data Systems.
HP’s management are now claiming Autonomy’s managers defrauded them and the deal has been referred to the US Securities and Exchange Commission and the UK Serious Fraud Office – a point which Autonomy’s former CEO, Mike Lynch, describes as nonsense given 300 HP managers and two major accounting companies carried out due diligence on the firm.
For HP this is another humiliation on a decade of embarrassment largely caused by poor leadership with poorly chosen CEOs including the hubristic Carly Fiorina, followed by the poster boy of entitled managerialism, Mark Hurd, who in turn was succeeded by the haplessly incompetent Leon Apotheker.
Apotheker was the wrong person to undo the mistakes of his predecessors however at least with the Autonomy purchase he was trying to clamber onto a technology trend before it left the station, unlike both Hurd and Fiorina who had missed opportunities and entered markets way too late. Although like Apotheker, they overpaid for acquisitions like Palm, EDS and 3Com.
In Fiorina’s case she had missed the dot com boom and subsequent bust while trashing the company’s brand by competing with Dell in the low end, lousy margin consumer PC industry.
Hurd’s solution was services, as shown by the $14 billion dollar acquisition of EDS. At the same time he took an axe to HPs costs and continued Fiorina’s gutting of HP’s core competences in R&D and high end industrial technology.
Like all managerialists, Mark didn’t apply the cost cutting mantra to himself, staying at the best hotels and flying the world on corporate jets like a latter Bourbon. A list of his expenses, along with the salaries for himself and his senior executive buddies, would embarrass a third-world kleptocrat.
When he left HP under the cloud of a sexual harrassment scandal, the board gave him a settlement of over $40 million dollars rather than the $27 million he was entitled to.
Most infamously, in the scandal that bought him down, a company ‘hostess’ claimed he stopped by an ATM in Madrid to show her the million he kept on call in his checking account.
It’s instructive that Roman emperors would have a slave reminding them that they were only mortal. Today’s managerial heroes have ‘hostesses’ to remind them of their entitled position of being hairy chested, virile heroes of 20th Century capitalism; even as their 1980s thinking destroyed shareholder wealth on an industrial scale.
One could ask why a company like HP would need ‘hostesses’ – particularly at a time when cost cutting was mandating office lights were turned off at 6pm. Just the fact pretty ladies could be on the company payroll to solely to stroke the egos of senior male executives is enough in itself to illustrate the mess HP had become.
With over $16 billion in write downs this year, sacking the eye-candy for over-privileged middle aged executives is the easier task for current HP CEO Meg Whitman. Whether she can manage to save HP from over a decade of poor management remains to be seen, but the shareholders will be hoping.
